Search by keyword or six-digit Content ID


What's Hot

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Castle Rock [Change Location]

Blog Entry 7 of 8 Where In The World Are The Castle Rock Democrats?
My name is Debbie Hill, and I am the District Captain for the Castle Rock Democrats. My blog is about the goings on of the Democrats in the District (which contains about 53,000 people)....our community service projects, our work on legislation and candidates, and how we are trying to grow our party in a County that has only about 20% Democrats.

IREA: Our 18th century energy co-op


On Saturday, July 25, about 137,000 people in portions of ten counties, including my Castle Rock District, received a letter in the mail from their electricity provider, the Intermountain Rural Electric Association (IREA), lambasting the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009, more commonly known as the Waxman-Markey Bill. This bill was recently passed by a bipartisan majority in the US House of Representatives and will be considered shortly in the US Senate. I have already received feedback from recipients of the letter, who were either laughing that anyone would send such rubbish, or angry that they belong to a co-op that is so shortsighted and misleading.

IREA has been around for a long time, their general manager has been with them for a long time, and they have pretty much been able to do whatever they wanted to for a long time without any oversight by the Public Utilities Commission, because they are a co-op. In fact, they are the largest electric co-op in Colorado. They are supposed to be accountable to us, the co-op members, who use the electric power they provide. IREA is known for: not believing in climate change, not believing in using alternative energy, and not believing in changing from doing business as usual with good ol' coal, except when forced. They don't believe in sitting down with Governor Ritter to join in the energy roundtable discussions, so 137,000 of us are left without a voice in Colorado's New Energy Economy, which is already providing new green jobs all over the state. They don't encourage energy efficiency, and they don't encourage you to know anything about their board's decisions or their elections. They do send a rebate check once a year to show you how wonderful they are, and they do tell you often how cheaply they provide you that reliable coal fueled energy.

In the letter, IREA predicts that if the Waxman-Markey bill is passed, then all hell will break loose, our economy will crumble and "millions" of jobs will go overseas. They go on to intimate that using wind and solar power will cause our lights to go out, and then finally say, hey, what are we worried about, it's not CO2 emissions, but sun spots, that are causing changes in the weather, but actually, the temperature is dropping! I kid you not! But maybe this is what we should expect from a company that gave a six figure sum a few years ago to an anti global warming organization, our co-op members' money, and is now spending more of our money to send us a partisan political piece of propaganda. They are so out of step with the industry that even their own National Rural Electric Association is not opposed to this bill.

I am a Democrat, but I do not automatically support everything that Democrats in Washington, DC and locally do. I am also a former oil and gas landman, and so I also understand where fossil fuels people are coming from. But this issue goes way beyond either politics or business. Passage in the House was a huge accomplishment towards having a comprehensive energy plan that is: good for the economy by providing investments in energy efficiency and creating green jobs, good for the environment by setting up a system to counteract CO2 and other emissions, as well as encourage clean energy alternatives like wind and solar power, and good for national security, by decreasing our dependence on foreign oil in a responsible manner. It is probably as important a bill to pass as the Clean Air Act and the Safe Drinking Water Act were, if not more so. The Congressional Budget office estimate of a postage stamp a day cost to a family is quite a bit more likely than IREA's $5000 and above citing, with significant savings as opposed to costs to families within a few years. The cost of doing nothing, not counting the huge subsidies to the coal, oil and gas and nuclear industries, would be disastrous to our economy, to say nothing of the environmental cost. China, who IREA mentions as not reducing their CO2 output, is no star in the world of environmental policy, but is massively overspending us in terms of investing in green energy alternatives.

So are the lights going out if we pass the bill? No one is flipping the switch tomorrow, or ever, to 100% wind energy, so no, the lights will not go out! This kind of scare tactic is beneath anyone.

And as to global warming, I hardly need to say that there is a huge consensus among scientists all over the world that global warming does exist, and that it poses a significant threat to life as we know it by creating negative changes an alarming rate. Denying this is as ludicrous as denying the existence of the Holocaust.

The sad bottom line is that IREA does not believe that this bill will help them sell their power, so they are against it. But the writing is on the wall. Will our co op continue to live in the 18 th century, and continue to kick and scream as it is pulled in the 21 st century? If so, then all of us will be penalized by their backwards behavior as they are made to tow the line on carbon constraints.

Seven committees in the Senate will take up the Waxman-Markey bill on September 8, including Senator Udall's Energy and Natural Resources Committee, and Senator Bennet's Agriculture Committee. I would urge you to call them, not as IREA would have you do, to defeat the bill, but to support it as the key to a smart energy future. Write letters to the editor too, and to IREA, and talk to your friends. And do keep an eye on what your co-op is up to, especially when it comes time to vote on their board members, and take a stand. It does not have to be business as usual anymore.

Guidelines: Be kind. Abusive commentary may be removed. If you believe someone has been abusive, please click "Report Abuse".

SUBMIT COMMENT
Talk Back : submit comments to the blog

*Note: you need to log-in to add a comment or rating.
Thank you! Your comment has been updated.
< BACK | NEXT >
Showing 1-10 of 28 comments

The real danger from the Association management is the use of this entire discussion about CO2 and Coal as a smokescreen to distract attention away from the large proposed rate increases. The 20-25% increase to fixed charges does not merit discussion about how they relate to actual costs. How are these changes justified during a period of declining materials costs and flat wage inflation? Were these expense increases actually incurred in a prior (election) year and withheld from the voters? Again, the lack of transparency clouds the actions of the levers behind the curtain. These are issues that require continued attention.

Beyond the inability of the Association management to speak clearly on the issues at hand it should not be surprising that Waxman-Markey cap and trade bill has weak support. The bill itself if so loaded with exemptions and buybacks to the big CO2 producers, coal companies and utilities as to be useless in actually meeting its objectives. Add to that the highest unemployment in a decade, a significant drop of consumer wealth in real estate and equities, the angst of voters already reeling from the Polisi Pork Package, the Big Bank Bailouts, ObamaMoters and the hurry-up offence on health care and you can understand current lack of support for yet another expensive bill from Washington. The Association management is grasping at straws by confusing the lack of support for Waxman-Markey as vindication for their 19th-century position on coal.

The overwhelming response to IREA’s position on the current Cap & Trade bill is positively underwhelming. No actual facts and figures are used in this claim. A positive response from four friends and family members do not constitute a mandate from the IREA customer base. The unwillingness of management to document their claims with the actual number of responses simply exposes the tenuous position of these claims. Last year the Association used claims from an alleged poll to support a position of continued focus on coal as a power source. At that time the Association was unable or unwilling to reply to my request for the full poll results, perhaps believing it is better to mislead the voters rather than reveal the actual results. The continued lack of transparency in this organization calls into question the current process of making decisions and then broadcasting facts to support them.

Debbie, thank you VERY much for your very rational response to the outrageous letter from IREA. I didn't think at the time to reverse their suggestion of calling our representatives, but I have let my preference known through Move On. Thanks again!

For the record, I think IREA does a fantastic job at providing electricity at a reasonable cost. That, after all, is their mission. Am I to assume that providing electricity at a reasonable cost is now a political issue and the Democrats, at least the one writing this article and the ones who comment in support, are against that? Oh, and by the way, Debbie, there was a recent election where all customers could vote for directors. You really come across as sour grapes. And, I appreciate the letters from IREA, otherwise I would probably not know what is going on with proposals to make my electricity unaffordable. GREAT JOB IREA!! THANK YOU!!

Well thought out article. Some people resort to name calling as a substitute for honest discussion. I wonder what their thoughts will be many years from now when they will be sitting in their rocking chairs wondering why they cannot breath through all the coal dust, why the crops won’t grow, and why water is being rationed year round.

I am not falling for this attack on IREA. I left New York a year and a half ago. I was paying $235 dollars a month on a budget to the Long Island power Authority. That amount was for my Household of 2 people, my wife and I, for Electricity only. I had installed the energy saving light bulbs and all energy efficient appliances back in NY. IREA is doing a great job keeping our bills low. We should be using common sense when addressing the environmental issues. Al Gore and Prince Charles are getting rich promoting their scare tactics on global warming. If you can afford the increase, you pay for the changes and they can leave my bill at the rates I pay now which is about a 3rd of what i paid in NY. Too many people make ridiculous comments about things before they do their homework. I think IREA should look at available options but if they are going to raise our rates a great deal they should stick with their current plan.

Debbie Hill's criticism of the IREA is preposterous on its face! She alleges that 137,000 people have no voice regarding the proposed CAP and TRADE legislation. She just does not like the outcome of fair elections held by the IREA for directors. The IREA membership supports its management which she criticizes as being out of touch. She is the one who is out of touch with the reality of this stupid legislation. She needs to educate herself on the true costs and stop the gross understatement in order to sell her position. It appears that she just does not like the outcome of a democratic election and what people truly support who don't agree with her position. Instead she slimes and belittles those who disagree with her.

Your article is appallingly shallow. What's a green job? Sounds like make-work.What's Waxman-Markey? Sounds like a tax, most hurtful to the poor. Watch your wallet folks when California Democrats lead on anything. Climate change assertions are shopworn. Consider their source: the U.N.IPCC, Al Gore, and scientists funded by grants with predisposed conclusions. Why not throw in Ward Churchill? Were global warming as plain as the nose on one's face, we'd all rally round the flag and get on board. Unfortunately, your party calls the honorable opposition "Global Warming Deniers", intellectually stuffing this hooey down our throats as if we were the equivalent of fools who believe that 6 million Jews didn't die in the Holocaust. I say get Ipecac to rid the national stomach of global warming poison, hoisting Stan on our shoulders. Courage is in short supply in America and we need leaders who speak the truth, not those needing to calibrate their words. Joe Gschwendtner

Debbie - are you aware of the existence of the IREA member/watchdog group "IREAvoices?" See the site at: www.ireavoices.org
Showing 1-10 of 28 comments
< BACK | NEXT >