register |  login
Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Tower
Blog
Blog Entry 6 of 130 Buzz by Barbara
I think about a lot of things. I have opinions about most. What good are thoughts and opinions when not shared? I'll show you mine if you'll show me yours. Issues related to education really get me going. I love to dine on the hot potatoes of school accountability, standardized testing, corporal punishment in schools (outlawed in only about 28 states), scrutiny of school staff before hiring, teacher performance standards, and the weeding out of bad apples in education. I promote fitness as the miracle drug most of us seek. No pill will duplicate the health benefits of working our bodies. I strongly support the adage, "Don't breed or buy while shelter animals die." The world does not need more puppies or kittens. A visit to a local shelter is proof. I consider myself schooled in basic personal money management, the entrepreneurial spirit, domestic adoption, motherood in middle age, Baby Boomer issues, Southern culture, and how to cook a meal in twenty minutes. Whew. So, where shall we start?

Plum Creek Medical - the priciest care in town?
Contributed by: Barbara Neff   on 4/7/2006

Two weeks ago my ten-year-old son's temperature shot to nearly 104 degrees while at school. The school nurse called. I immediately went to the school, got my son and headed for Plum Creek Medical. My son had not been treated there, though other members of our family have.

We did not have an appointment, of course. But, the reception staff handed me the requisite stack of forms and said my son could be seen by a doctor shortly. We probably waited a half hour.

My son was briefly examined by Dr. Jack England in an entirely routine manner. Dr. England quickly surmised my son was stricken with the flu running quite rampant among school children. A flu culture was conducted. A prescription for Tamiflu was written. A dose of Advil was administered.

Today I received a copy of the charges for my son's unscheduled visit to Plum Creek Medical. Here is how the total whopping charge of $298.00 breaks down:

New patient charge: $154.00

"Urgent care" visit: $90.00

Flu culture $54.00

I called Plum Creek Medical to make certain there was no mistake. No, I was told by a billing representative. No mistake.

Since these charges seem out of line, I called other medical facilities in the area to get prices. I presented exactly the scenario of my son's visit to Plum Creek Medical. I asked how much an office visit would be for a sick ten-year-old boy with no appointment who had never before been a patient.

Founders Family Medical in Castle Rock quoted $56. Extra charges could be incurred, of course, for lab fees, should lab work be necessary. No extra charges for being a new patient and no tacked on charges for being a walk-in, though they encourage appointments.

Willard Family Practice at the intersection of Arapahoe Road and Jordan quoted $76 for the office visit, which includes all new patient fees, extra for lab and no extra charges for being a walk-in, though they encourage appointments.

I am wondering. Does Plum Creek Medical's $154.00 charge for a "new patient" visit that involved no extra or special services of any sort and $90 charge for being a walk-in (deemed urgent care) seem excessive to anyone but me?

Though I have never price-shopped medical care providers before, it sure seems like a good idea now.




SUBMIT COMMENT

Rate the above blog



Current Rating

Based on 1 user ratings.

Talk Back : submit comments to the blog

*Note: you need to log-in to add a comment or rating.

Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
Submitted By: Barbara Neff
posted on 4/8/2006 @ 8:44:38 AM
(Not Rated)
Julie and Angela, thank you for your perspectives. Why does it feel shallow or even slimy to price shop medical care providers? As we have all learned, medical care providers are competitive businesses. Consumers should price shop as well as shop for the best patient services for the dollar. If more people were less reluctant to talk money as it relates to health care we consumers might reap better care at better prices.
Submitted By: Angela Copeland
posted on 4/7/2006 @ 6:00:59 PM
Rated Blog Entry
I had never price-shopped medical care until recently. It was my husband's idea. He needed a non-emergency surgery, and the surgeon had privileges at several hospitals. There ended up being a pretty big difference among hospitals. Funny thing is, when my husband told one hospital he was going to another for surgery because they were less expensive, the second hospital told him they would try to match the price quoted by the other hospital. You would have thought we were trying to buy a car. Very weird. I never knew that the price would vary so greatly for the same service. I guess it is just like anything else!
Submitted By: Julie Robinson
posted on 4/7/2006 @ 3:38:55 PM
(Not Rated)
I didn't know they did flu cultures. Maybe tamiflu would have worked for my daughter who has been very sick with my "doctor mom" diagnosed flu. I have been to the doctor so many times where they have said something was a flu or virus and left with nothing. Try Dr. Stage in town, if he has any openings for new patients, he is just the best! He isn't expensive, and is so practical. We had to switch to Kaiser Permanente for health care reasons and transfered away from Dr. Stage. He calls your house if your child has been to see him and was very sick. Who does that?
Showing 1-3 of 3 comments
CONTRIBUTOR INFORMATION

Barbara Neff

Castle Rock , CO

Barbara Neff has posted 130 blog entries and 839 comments since joining on 9/14/2005. Barbara Neff 's average blog rating is 4.97.
SAVE AND SHARE THIS BLOG ENTRY
BLOG ENTRY RSS FEEDS
WANT TO WRITE FOR YOURHUB.COM?
Want to see the stories you write and the photos you shoot featured in the YourHub.com Thursday print section available all over the Front Range and with home subscriptions of the Rocky Mountain News and The Denver Post? All you have to do is  register,  then post a story or column, start a blog or tell everyonewhat events are happening in town. We will print the best stories, columns, event listings, photos and blog entries in our print sections.

ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad

Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad