register |  login
Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Tower

Nintendo Wii beats Apple TV
Contributed by: Alexis Gentry on 5/31/2007

Yesterday, Apple announced that it's Apple TV will soon be able to stream YouTube videos. Apple CEO Steve Jobs was quoted saying, "This is the first time users can easily browse, find and watch YouTube videos right from their living room couch." After reading the quote, I was left feeling a little confused.

I've been browsing, finding and watching YouTube videos right from my living room couch for weeks now on my Nintendo Wii, which connects wirelessly to the internet and includes an Opera browser. With my Wii, which costs $50 less than the Apple TV, I'm not only able to watch videos on YouTube, but I can browse any site on the net and bookmark favorites just as easily as I can on my computer. Oh, and the Wii also plays some amazing games!

I admit, I thought the Apple TV was cool when I first saw it in the Apple store. Watching the videos in my iTunes library (and thanks to programs like TubeSock and HandBrake I have hundreds) on my TV was a cool opportunity. The other features, like watching movies or listening to my music, were pretty inconsequential. I already have speakers for my iPod and can rent all the movies I want to see from Netflix on DVD for as little as $4.99. The iTunes store, by comparison, makes me pay $9.99 for a movie that only plays on my iPod and doesn't even include any special features or bonus material.

While the movie and music features didn't interest me, viewing other videos from my iTunes library on my TV did pique my interest. I've built up quite a library of clips from TV shows, user-uploaded concert videos, and occasionally entire episodes of my favorite cancelled TV shows by ripping them from YouTube. Apple TV seemed to be the only thing that could bring all these clips to my TV.

Then I got the Wii.

One of the first things I did after nearly wearing out my arm playing all the Wii Sports games was to try out the Opera-powered internet browser. The Wii connected to my wireless network and I was able to browse webpages quickly and easily. Naturally, I checked out Trashwire and the Trashwire Blog to see how it looked on my TV.

After skimming the blog posts, I decided to try to watch one of the embedded YouTube videos. To my pleasant surprise, it loaded really fast and played right there on my TV. I immediately went to youtube.com to see more videos, finding all my favorites and playing them in full-screen mode as if they were on-demand clips. I couldn't help but think to myself, "If someone could get the Wii, why on earth would they want an Apple TV?"

The best part of viewing the videos on the Wii is that there's no need for me to rip them from YouTube, pay a cent for them on the Apple Store, or spend any time converting them to a format that will work on my TV. I simply visit youtube.com, find the video I want and click play just like I would if I was checking out the video on my computer.

Here's an example. Trashwire readers know I am a huge fan of My Chemical Romance. Yesterday, the band released the brand new video for their song "Teenagers". The video isn't even available on the iTunes store yet, so that rules out paying $1.99 to download it to my computer. If I had the Apple TV and I still wanted to watch the video in my living room, I could go to the band's YouTube channel, find the new video ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6EQAOmJrbw), save it on my computer and convert it using TubeSock, add it to my iTunes library, then sync it to my Apple TV and watch it. That's quite a few steps. The Wii makes it easy to watch the video on my TV without any downloading or converting. I just power on the console, go to the Internet Channel, click on YouTube (which I bookmarked to make it even faster), and watch the video right from the YouTube page. With the Wii, it's like having the entire YouTube library on your TV on demand.

While both products don't directly compete with one another (the Wii is a game console, the Apple TV is a home media system) their features are not mutually exclusive. The Wii also includes a photo application that lets you view pictures from any SD memory card right on your screen. You can also add MP3s to your memory card and listen to music during photo slide shows if you're so inclined. Both of these features are hyped up as being ground-breaking and revolutionary by Apple, but they're not even the main highlights of the Wii. The Wii does all those things and plays games, lets you create and share cool avatars called Wii Miis, includes a weather and news feed to keep you updated, and lets you play classic Nintendo and Sega games in the Virtual Console.

Since both the Apple TV and the Nintendo Wii have some similar functions, it seems like a natural choice to pick the one that does all that and more, especially if it costs $50 less.
_____________________________

Alexis Gentry is the editor of Trashwire.com.




SUBMIT COMMENT

Rate the above story



Current Rating

Based on 9 user ratings.

Talk Back : submit comments to the story

*Note: you need to log-in to add a comment or rating.

Showing 1-7 of 7 comments
Submitted By: durga kalavagunta
posted on 1/1/2008 @ 3:51:31 PM
(Not Rated)
Good article. I think nothing beats the fact that you can watch more than just youtube videos on your TV with the moowee.tv application. I love the fact that internet video watching is a TV experience rather than a PC experience using moowee. I can watch favorite clips with my famiy and friends...without them crowding over my shoulder like at a PC...and all from the comfort of my couch. Oh BTW did you know you can also share your favorite clips with friends and family just by the mere click of a button. My daughter who was away for the holidays loves the feature. She sends me her favorite Hello Kitty and High School musical videos all the time along with her comments on it and I feel connected with her even tho' she is miles away for a few days. Jacquard
Submitted By: Jay Vas
posted on 6/7/2007 @ 5:00:00 AM
(Not Rated)
Hmmm...nice.. Alexis. You are right on...and thanks KH for pointing the moowee.tv site. I like their custom channel creation feature, thats part of the search.
Submitted By: K H
posted on 6/6/2007 @ 4:16:10 PM
Rated Story
Excellent article. Completely agree with your analysis. I came across a service called moowee.tv for the Nintendo Wii which makes watching Youtube easy. With this application the Wii remote and UI is optimized for TV watching.
Submitted By: James Jackson
posted on 6/4/2007 @ 1:41:41 PM
(Not Rated)
You could use www.orb.com to watch those iTunes videos for free. It'd make your Wii even more valuable! :) - Captain Context www.captaincontext.com
Submitted By: joe g
posted on 6/4/2007 @ 1:08:20 PM
(Not Rated)
PCs with TV out could do it years ago... Then theres that whole HD Video thing that you forgot to mention, which I'm pretty sure is Apple TV's biggest draw. People won't buy Apple TV to watch crappy quality youtube vids on their TV.
Submitted By: Jason Tucker
posted on 6/4/2007 @ 12:27:19 PM
(Not Rated)
My hacked original xbox running xbox media center was able to view youtube videos way before the PS3 or Wii. *shrug*
Submitted By: ed dj
posted on 6/4/2007 @ 11:11:31 AM
(Not Rated)
hmmm nice post but the wii wasnt the first game console to view youtube videos... technically the PS3 had launched 4 days prior to the wii with its own browser and yes. I watched youtube + myspace on the ps3 before the wii. Now hte part that you do win is that you save 50$ on the wii over apple. and ps3 is 600$, but u get HD youtube videos on it, and cant on the wii. crunshii~
Showing 1-7 of 7 comments
CONTRIBUTOR INFORMATION

Alexis Gentry

Denver , CO

Alexis Gentry has posted 48 stories and 8 comments since joining on 2/8/2007. Alexis Gentry 's average story rating is 4.87.
SAVE AND SHARE THIS STORY
STORY RSS FEEDS
WANT TO WRITE FOR YOURHUB.COM?
Want to see the stories you write and the photos you shoot featured in the YourHub.com Thursday print section available all over the Front Range and with home subscriptions of the Rocky Mountain News and The Denver Post? All you have to do is register, then post a story or column, start a blog or tell everyone what events are happening in town. We will print the best stories, columns, event listings, photos and blog entries in our print sections.

ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad

Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad