register |  login
Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Tower

Group opposes statue of fallen Navy SEAL Dietz
Contributed by: YourHub.com on 4/5/2007

The city of Littleton is in the process of establishing a memorial to Danny Dietz, a Navy SEAL and Littleton native who was killed in action in Afghanistan on June 28, 2005. A statue of Dietz holding his rifle at "parade rest" will be part of the memorial that will be dedicated July 4, two years to the day after his body was recovered.

A group of parents is opposing the statue and its location in the memorial planned for Berry Park because they say, since Dietz is holding a rifle in the depiction, it glorifies violence, and is inappropriate for the location blocks away from three schools and two playgrounds. Goddard Middle School, Community School for the Gifted and Cetennial Elementary School are all near the park.

Following is a press release sent April 5 by the city of Littleton -- it's moving ahead with the memorial -- and following that is a memo written by Littleton Historical Director Tim Nimz givng a brief history of military memorials.

FACT SHEET

Danny Dietz Memorial

· Danny Dietz was awarded the Navy Cross for "...extraordinary heroism in actions against the enemy..." while serving in a four-man Special Reconnaissance team in Afghanistan. "Operating in the middle of an enemy-controlled area, in extremely rugged terrain ...Petty Officer Dietz fought valiantly against the numerically superior and positionally advantaged enemy force...valiantly defending his teammates and himself in a harrowing gunfight, until he was mortally wounded."

· The City of Littleton became involved in the project at the request of United States Congressman Tom Tancredo in the summer of 2006. Congressman Tancredo asked that the city work with the Dietz family to create a permanent memorial to Danny in the community where he grew up.

· The project began with a meeting that included city staff, members of the Dietz family, and representatives from Littleton veterans organizations, including State Representative Joe Rice. Strong support was expressed for moving forward with a permanent memorial.

· The Berry Park extension site was selected because the vacant lot was recently acquired by the city and funds were budgeted in 2007 to develop it. The park is in the same neighborhood where Danny grew up and attended elementary and middle school and where his parents still reside.

· A fundraising effort in the winter of 2006 resulted in contributions in excess of $42,000 contributed by individuals, businesses, and non profit organizations. There is no city money (excluding staff time) in the project. The city is providing space for the sculpture on public land.

· There has been an extensive public process for the memorial with two cover stories in the October and December issues of the Littleton Report and a story in the February issue.

· An RFP process concluded in December, 2006 with the selection of Canon City Sculptor Robert Henderson as the winning artist. The sculpture is based on one of the last photos taken of Danny prior to his death and it means a great deal to his family.

· There have been two city council votes on the contract for the sculpture, one in January and one in February. Each vote was unanimous. A clay model of the sculpture was displayed at one of the meetings.

· There has been extensive coverage of the project in the Littleton Independent, Villager, Denver Post, Rocky Mountain News, the Kaplis and Silverman Show on KHOW, and on television Channels 2, 4, 7, 9 and 31.

· The artist has been paid 2/3 of the cost ($20,000). The bronze sculpture is at the foundry and is scheduled for dedication July 4, 2007. Staff is working with Navy officials to plan the dedication which will include a keynote speech by an admiral who is flying in for the ceremony and a flyover with aircraft from Buckley.

· An objection to the memorial was raised by a citizen at the March 20 city council meeting, expressing concern about the gun that Danny is wearing as part of his uniform/equipment.

· There are thousands of memorials across the country (see memo from Littleton Historical Museum Director Tim Nimz) which feature a military man or woman in uniform with his/her weapon. These memorials are visited by millions of school children and adults each year.

· The City of Littleton respects that there are other points of view regarding military memorials.


Tim Nimz memo

From: Tim Nimz, Museum Director

Date April 4, 2007

Re: Military memorials in the United States

Although there appears to be no definitive hard count of military-themed memorials and monuments in the United States, my research indicates that it is safe to state that they number in the thousands. Military historians estimate that there have been more than 100,000 military engagements in the nation's 11 major wars and countless smaller actions since the late-18th century, each of them desperately important to the soldiers who fought in them, their families and loved ones, and the country they represented. Inevitably, memorials and monuments, both large and small, were erected to commemorate these conflicts and to honor the men and women who served. For example, the Civil War generated at least 1,538 military memorials; World War I produced at least 950; and the Vietnam War at least 62.

Many of these memorials are located in highly public areas. Through the first half of the 20th century, it was quite common to find a war memorial in town and city squares throughout the country. Since the end of WWII, these more generic "war" memorials have given way to monuments honoring specific individuals. Martial-themed statues, in particular, have always been very popular, dating from the time of the American Revolution through the current War on Terrorism. Most major cities, and many smaller ones, prominently display these statues in public spaces, including parks, intersections, and the grounds of government facilities. Perhaps most famous is the Minute Man Statue, commemorating the battles of Lexington and Concord which opened the Revolutionary War, located in Minute Man National Historical Park in suburban Boston. Certainly, no space in the United States is more public than the National Mall in Washington, DC. The Mall, visited by approximately 24 million people each year, hosts three major war memorials for WWII, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War.

A great many of these monuments depict soldiers in uniform and carrying their service weapons, although few show the soldiers engaged in combat. The Minute Man, mentioned above, is armed with a flintlock "Brown Bess" musket (the same weapon that the opposing British Army used). Service weapons, usually sheathed or unsheathed cavalry sabers or swords, appear in many of the 56 martial-themed statues in the District of Columbia, including almost all of the equestrian statues that dominate the major street intersections. The Korean War Memorial on the Mall features statues of 19 service men in a patrol formation carrying typical military equipment, including M-1 and M-14 rifles. The Three Servicemen Statue, located next to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial (the famous "wall") on the Mall, depicts three soldiers with M-16 rifles and an M-60 machine gun. The Colorado State Capitol in Denver has two military statues on the grounds, a Civil War monument/memorial with a Union soldier with gun in hand, and a statue of Joseph P. Martinez, the first Hispanic Coloradan to receive the Medal of Honor, carrying his service weapon.


Editor's note: To post your own thoughts about the Danny Dietz statue and memorial controversy,click here. To post, you first need to become a YourHub.com registered user --click here to do that.



SUBMIT COMMENT

Rate the above story



Current Rating

Based on 2 user ratings.

Talk Back : submit comments to the story

*Note: you need to log-in to add a comment or rating.

Showing 1-5 of 5 comments
Submitted By: Bill Morgan
posted on 4/11/2007 @ 12:07:27 PM
(Not Rated)
Freedom does not come about through idealism, but through the defense of ideals through sacrifice. Some would idealistically desire to achieve a higher level of society by erasing the awareness of these kinds of sacrifices, but such a society has never existed and can never exist because the just society is formed precisely THROUGH the sacrifices of those who defend our highest ideals, sometimes at the cost of their own blood. The memorial honors one among them - and reminds us who we are, and to whom we owe what we enjoy.
Submitted By: Robert House
posted on 4/7/2007 @ 8:41:57 AM
(Not Rated)
Emily Cassidy and Linda Cuesta's hysterical objections to this proud memorial of a fallen US hero is an excellent example of the cancer-like emasculation that is gripping this great country at a time when we least can afford to go soft.
Submitted By: Norm Brown
posted on 4/6/2007 @ 5:03:44 PM
(Not Rated)
I would suggest that the fear of the inclusion of a rifle, stems from a lack of rationality. This is not a statue of the killers at Columbine. This is a statue of a man who died while protecting the rights of women. He needed a tool to protect us all from tyranny. Tyranny not unlike that the protesters would impose on everyone else arising from their uncontrolled emotion. The rifle no more glorifies violence than Emily Cassidy glorifies stupidity. Norm Brown
Submitted By: Raul Roddy
posted on 4/6/2007 @ 12:44:56 PM
(Not Rated)
I recently learned of opposition to this memorial by at least two bumble heads. I was almost speechless....what these people, Linda Cuesta and Emily Cassidy, should do is go to that memorial and thank God that there are men like Danny Dietz protecting their very right to make asses out of themselves. Speechless...that is where I find myself.
Submitted By: Jared Keller
posted on 4/5/2007 @ 10:20:28 PM
Rated Story
Five stars for the article - a fractional star for the fluffy-minded polyannas who oppose the statue because of its inclusion of a rifle. The irrational fear that surrounds firearms is merely another expression of what John Stossel has appropriately labelled the "Fear-Industrial Complex". Show Dietz in his uniform - the uniform (and equipment) that he willingly wore in defense of the rest of us. To blithely obscure the obvious danger faced and sacrifices made by "rough men ready to do violence on our behalf" is to deny the cost and value of that sacrifice.
Showing 1-5 of 5 comments
SAVE AND SHARE THIS STORY
STORY RSS FEEDS
WANT TO WRITE FOR YOURHUB.COM?
Want to see the stories you write and the photos you shoot featured in the YourHub.com Thursday print section available all over the Front Range and with home subscriptions of the Rocky Mountain News and The Denver Post? All you have to do is register, then post a story or column, start a blog or tell everyone what events are happening in town. We will print the best stories, columns, event listings, photos and blog entries in our print sections.

ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad

Loading Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Loading Ad